My Mama’s Potato Salad Recipe (2024)

(5 from 13 votes)

This is so delicious!!!!! I made it for a potluck at work tomorrow! 😁

I made it for Super Bowl. My husband said it was the best I had ever made. Everyone liked it.

Wow!!! I have NEVER been a fan of the traditional mayo based salads, thought it was disgusting all that mayo and mush. My Mama made a marvelous vinegar & oil & egg potato salad. Seeing as I don’t do oil or eggs anymore, gave this a try. Sooooo delicious, wow, keeper recipe!

I read through a few WFPB potato salad recipes before settling on this one and I’m not disappointed! I’m amazed at how much it tastes the the potato salad I used to love from the grocery store deli. I would definitely feel comfortable making this to share with non-vegans as well. I don’t think they’d even know it was WFPB!

I can't use up leftovers for 8 servings very darn often. So I made this with one potato and it worked. I just whisked together everything but the potato and then mixed in the potato. I did add a little homemade soy yogurt to make it smoother. But A okay. I was specifically looking for a tofu version of potato salad. Thank you Dell!!

I saw that the recipe has 3 tbsp total of mustard. I can tolerate mustard. For example I don't mind it in the store bought potato salad. Does this have a very strong mustard taste? Thanks. It sounds so good.

No, not a forward mustard flavour. You can taste that it’s present; but it’s not over powering

I am waiting to try this recipe.

Hun can you please tell me why she used the tofu. Cause you already used potatoes so I'm not sure why you'd need tofu. Please help.

Tofu is used in place of mayo… for creaminess.

A Potato salad with a big protein hit from the tofu- great for those watching their macros!

My husband and I both enjoyed this potato salad. He is not a whole good type of guy so I love when he likes something that is delectable and healthy. I find it is so much easier to make with tofu than raw cashews which are not easily available to me.

My first time using tofu vs cashews as a mayonnaise replacement. It was very good! I didn't tell my omni family and no one noticed a difference! I tweaked recipe to replicate my mom's recipe by using Italian seasoning and omitting relish. I already had extra firm tofu (not silken) and added some water to the blender make it more creamy.

Just a question before making it. I’ve never seen silken tofu that was firm or extra firm. Just says silken on the various brands. I have regular firm tofu that I plan to use. Will that work? Or better to use silken that isn’t rated firm or extra firm?

Hi Lindsay, I have the same question, I'm trying silken tofu. What did you use, and how did it turn out?

Mori-Nu brand (shelf stable, so sometimes in the Asian food section at grocers) is silken and has different firmness categories. Several cookbooks have noted that there is not significant difference between them — it might make for a slightly more liquid/firm sauce, but I’d imagine any would work.

I used 10oz of ordinary silken tofu, and it turned out great! Keeping this recipe!

Thank you SO much for this recipe! I've been searching for a recipe that tasted like what I made prior to adopting a plant-based lifestyle-this is it! I made this potato salad today and it is AMAZING!!!

When I can’t find firm silken tofu I press soft silken tofu to take out the water

Could you replace the tofu with plain almond milk yogurt?

89g of carbs for one serving?

It's my husband, with coronary artery disease, that I am trying to satisfy. My daughter & I love pretty much everything on this site. He willingly went whole food plant based NO fat, but boy oh boy he doesn't do well with so very many salads & greens & the likes. He's 6'4", 190 pounds & it's really hard to fill him up. He. Loved. This!! And it sticks to his bony ribs. lol So happy. So thankful. FYI, he hadn't eaten beef or pork in over 10 years after finding out he had the hereditary sticky cholesterol. His dad died at 56. But even whilst eating only poultry, fish & olive oil he developed a 100% blocked artery & a second one at 45-50%. Dr. Calwell Esselstyn's "Prevent & Reverse Heart Disease" started our journey... the Food Revolution led me here where most of the recipes fit within our diet parameters.He's 61 & plans to live another healthy 30+ years.

What was the dill pickle relish for that was listed in ingredients.

You add it in step 3.

Leisa, so glad your husband discovered the problems with his arteries. I had the same issue. Have been a vegetarian--vegan about 70% of the time--and exercised, didn't smoke, didn't drink alcohol, didn't use drugs, didn't have diabetes or kidney issues, and no heart issues. I was not a candidate for peripheral arterial disease, and because of this, doctors could not figure out what was wrong with my legs--why I was starting to have so much trouble walking. A very observant podiatrist referred me to a practice whose only focus is blocker arteries. Thankfully, they found the severe blockage I had in both legs and cleaned them out. They told me if it had gone undetected for much longer, I probably would have had to have my leg amputated!!! As with your hubby, my problem was strictly hereditary, and that's why no doctor before even thought that might be the issue.I am telling everyone to get their arteries checked. This disease is silent until the blockage becomes severe. The test is painless and takes about 30 minutes. The procedure to remove the plaque is an in-office visit that takes about an hour, but you're there anywhere from 3-5 hours for prep, the procedure, and recovery. There is virtually no pain at all with this procedure, and it is covered by most insurances. Even though I'm a long-time vegetarian, I am now switching to a whole-foods, plant-based diet entirely. Please, everyone, do not neglect this advice--it could save your leg!!!

I would love to know the macro nutrient breakdown for this recipie.FatsCarbsProteinThanks!

Me too, especially the fat grams

Nutritional analysis per servingCalories: 460; Fat: 6 g; Saturated fat: 1 g; Trans fat: 0 g; Carbs: 89 g; Fiber: 12 g; Sugars: 13 g; Protein: 20 g; Sodium: 416 mg; Calcium: 343 mg;

Incredible taste! One of my friends said it was the best potato salad she's ever had, and I certainly did not tell her that I substituted tofu for mayonnaise. No one could tell the difference anyway. Thanks

SPOT. ON. This tasted exactly like my grandmother's potato salad. I have never used tofu before and didn't know what to do with it, so I recommend draining it and drying it (I didn't) so the sauce isn't too runny. Outside of that, I followed the recipe exactly with a generous amount of black pepper. It was excellent. Thank you.

Hi Heather, my wife, now a vegetarian, had some 6 or 7 strokes in 2017 and not only have I become her 24/7 Caregiver, I am also the cook, dishwasher, shopper, maid, etc., etc. I have been vegan since 2005 and love it! Tofu has become a staple in our house and the only time I dried it was when drying it for back-packing or making a mock jerky many years ago. I purchase only Organic Water-packed and after opening (Over The Sink) I drain and generally press it by hand to rid some of the water. If your hands are small or you would rather not use your hands, there are a number of Tofu presses on the market (check Amazon). I generaly purchase Extra-Firm as I can easily use it in most things from Tofu Scrample to sauces. I really like the sound of this recipe and will be trying it soon!! Thank you Del Sroufe for the recipe

I ❤ potato salad and this recipe is a great guide even w/o tofu. I added red pepper, fresh herbs, and doubled the dijon and lemon juice.

Hi Yvonne, Did you use the tofu in the above recipe? ❣

Thank you for this recipe! Since I changed to WFPB, I have really been missing potato salad. I made this recipe as directed, except that I used six medium Idaho potatoes and doubled both mustards. I gave my wife a taste, and I almost could not convince her to eat more, as she said that it had to be "cheating!" I made this with barbeque (soy curls and Hughes SF barbeque sauce) with sides of black-eyed peas and steamed broccoli. What a dinner!!